Cloverfield like Snakes On a Plane before it, was subject to massive amounts of internet geek hype. I ignored most of it, J.J. Abrams’ and Drew Goddard’s involvement was enough for me to get excited. The released trailer just solidified my decision that I had to see it.
Plot-wise the movie is incomplete. And I love it that way. The cameraman character, Hud, has an an obvious crush on one of the other survivors, but this never gets resolved. We never find out where the monster is from, or why it is doing what it’s doing. What exactly happens when you get bitten by one of the parasites never gets fully explained. And it’s perfect that way. Not only would it not fit in the format of the movie (shot handheld by one of the characters), but it adds a sense of realism. A sense of confusion that allows you to identify with the characters more.
Another excellent attribute of the movie is its pacing, or rather its lack thereof. While it’s the usual “high tension followed by calm recollecting” formula, the frequency and length of these vary so much it feels very arhythmic.
There’s not much to be said about the cinematography, aside from the fact that we get enough shots of the floor and the like to successfully uphold the illusion that this is an inexperienced individual filming.
Now, there is the matter of the supposed 9/11 allegory. Aside from the very beginning where people are running away from crumbling buildings and huge clouds of ash, it never really seems to live up to this idea. It’s just a good ol’ fashioned monster romp.
With all that said, there a few minor nitpicks that I have with the movie. Which mostly have to do with the fourth wall being broken. The opening card claims that the format of the recording is on a SD card, yet characters keep referring to a tape and occasionally bursts of video shot earlier come through, as if it were shot on tape.
Also, the military seems to be awfully quick to allow a few civilians to go out on their own in a warzone. While helpful to get the plot moving along, I just couldn’t buy it (I know, I know, 7-story tall monsters, you bitching about that, blah blah).
And finally, there is talk of a sequel, and I really don’t want that to happen. It’ll inevitably succumb to fan pressure and start to explain things. Let Cloverfield stand as a single experience and keep it all mystery.
In the end I’ve got to give Cloverfield a big FSFunky’s stamp of approval.
For some additional viewing and exactly why I feel this way, I recommend J. J. Abrams TED Talk. There is some interesting stuff in there.